Hayden Panettiere's new man

Hayden Panettiere's new man

Hayden Panettiere's new man. Meet Hayden Panettiere’s New Man-NFL Player Scotty McKnight. We thought Hayden Panettiere was dating New York Jets quarterback March Sanchez a few weeks ago when they were spotted at an In-N-Out burger in Laguna Hills, CA. We got our players confused, apparently. The Scream 4 actress is actually dating Sanchez’s teammate and friend from childhood Scotty McKnight, according to Us Magazine. The new couple were spotted in West Hollywood May 20th at Mel’s Diner.